2
Surveying Engineering Department, Ahar Azad University, Ahar, Iran
10.22059/jesphys.2026.415915.1007790
چکیده
Accurate spatial forecasting of aftershocks remains a critical challenge in seismology. The Deep Learning approach of DeVries et al. (2018) reported an AUC of 0.849 on a single held-out test set and has been widely adopted as a benchmark. We compare the DeepMLP (DeVries18 architecture) against four gradient-boosting methods—AdaBoost, XGBoost, CatBoost, and LightGBM—for binary classification of 5 km grid cells on the same SRCMOD and ISC dataset. Our central finding is a systematic rank reversal. Spearman rank correlations between test and 5-fold cross-validation (CV) rankings are strongly negative for Accuracy (ρ=−1.00), Average Precision (ρ=−0.90), and AUC (ρ=−0.70). The MLP achieves the highest test AUC (0.851) but ranks last in CV (0.751±0.019), while LightGBM and XGBoost achieve the highest CV AUC (0.798), with gaps of only +0.015 to 0.018. The MLP exhibits four pathologies: extreme data-hunger (CV AUC = 0.516 at 10% data), training-budget insensitivity (ΔAUC = +0.008 from 30 to 200 epochs), high variance with calibration reversal (CV std = 0.019; Brier 0.182 → 0.227), and unreliable uncertainty (r = −0.31 between uncertainty and error). We further report bootstrap 95% confidence intervals, F1-optimal thresholds, DeLong and McNemar tests, calibration analysis, cross-model SHAP agreement, and uncertainty quantification. LightGBM and CatBoost are statistically indistinguishable (DeLong p=0.465). Cross-model SHAP agreement is weak (minimum ρ=0.18). The MLP is 4.1× more uncertain than LightGBM and is the only model whose uncertainty is anti-correlated with error (r=−0.31). We recommend LightGBM for operational deployment due to its superior CV performance (0.798) and low training cost (4.8 s).
راست بود، اصغر و Jahanghiri، Nima. (1405). Cross-Validated Aftershock Pattern Forecasting: Deep Learning vs. Gradient Boosting. (e109908). فیزیک زمین و فضا، ()، e109908 https://doi.org/10.22059/jesphys.2026.415915.1007790
MLA
راست بود، اصغر، و Jahanghiri، Nima. "Cross-Validated Aftershock Pattern Forecasting: Deep Learning vs. Gradient Boosting" .e109908 ، فیزیک زمین و فضا، ، 1405، e109908. doi: 10.22059/jesphys.2026.415915.1007790
HARVARD
راست بود، اصغر، و Jahanghiri، Nima. (1405). 'Cross-Validated Aftershock Pattern Forecasting: Deep Learning vs. Gradient Boosting'، فیزیک زمین و فضا، (), e109908. doi: 10.22059/jesphys.2026.415915.1007790
CHICAGO
راست بود، اصغر و Jahanghiri، Nima، "Cross-Validated Aftershock Pattern Forecasting: Deep Learning vs. Gradient Boosting." فیزیک زمین و فضا، (1405): e109908, doi: 10.22059/jesphys.2026.415915.1007790
VANCOUVER
راست بود اصغر، Jahanghiri Nima. Cross-Validated Aftershock Pattern Forecasting: Deep Learning vs. Gradient Boosting. JESP. 1405;():e109908. doi: 10.22059/jesphys.2026.415915.1007790